Coffee House Writers

Top Menu

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Article Categories
    • Creativity
    • Culture
    • Design
    • Family
    • Fashion
    • Fiction
    • Food
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home
    • Lifestyle
    • Media
    • Memories
    • Music
    • Nonfiction
    • Poetry
    • Politics
    • Relationships
    • Sports
    • Style
    • Technology
    • Travel
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Founder
  • Meet Our Admin
    • Chief Editors
    • Editors
    • Poetry Editors
    • Advertising Team
    • Recruiting Team
    • Book Club
  • Testimonials
  • Apply
  • Login

logo

Coffee House Writers

  • Home
  • Article Categories
    • Creativity
    • Culture
    • Design
    • Family
    • Fashion
    • Fiction
    • Food
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home
    • Lifestyle
    • Media
    • Memories
    • Music
    • Nonfiction
    • Poetry
    • Politics
    • Relationships
    • Sports
    • Style
    • Technology
    • Travel
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Founder
  • Meet Our Admin
    • Chief Editors
    • Editors
    • Poetry Editors
    • Advertising Team
    • Recruiting Team
    • Book Club
  • Testimonials
  • Apply
  • Login
  • Ma Millie-3

  • Blooming

  • The Fool

  • Enigma

  • Why an Amazing Choir Director Absolutely Changes the World

  • Mr. Keith’s House – Part IV

  • Facing Old Foes 

  • Same Day, Different Universe – 3

  • Hope

  • Crescent Moons Part 31

  • The North Wind – Part 6

  • Emily Part II

  • Roaring Pageant Murders: Part Three

  • Part 2: They Came For Munchies

  • How to Self-Edit

  • My Freedom, Mon Amor

  • Arvid, Chapter 2

  • The Untouchable and Invisible World

  • The Mystery of Cash Castle: Part 10

  • Like A Naked Branch

  • The radiance on his face

  • Pillows

  • 5 Benefits of Touch

  • CRESCENT MOONS PART 30

  • Stone Walls

  • 2023: Year Of Dreams

  • Same Day Different Universe – Part 2

  • Monrovia

  • Circle of a Day

  • The Mystery of Cash Castle: Part 9

FamilyHomeEntertainmentLifestyleNonfictionCulture
Home›Family›Book Review: The Giver

Book Review: The Giver

By Jasmine Bell
September 28, 2020
4217
0
Share:
A library book of the book cover of The Giver
Photo by Jasmine Bell

WARNING: This book review contains spoilers! 

The Giver is a classic children’s novel about a twelve-year-old boy who learns the deep complexity of his dystopian world. Written by Lois Lowry, author of, Number the Stars. It’s the first book in The Giver Quartet series and received the John Newbery Medal.

The book’s premise:

“Jonas’ world is perfect. Everything is under control. There is no war, fear, or pain. There are no choices. Every person has an assigned role in The Community. 

Singled out to become the next Receiver of Memories, Jonas receives special training from the current Receiver. He alone holds the memories of the true pain and pleasure of life. Now it’s time for the old Receiver to give Jonas the truth. There is no turning back.”

Review:

I heard about this book back in middle school and in high school, but never read it until recently. The book cover is a little strange to me because it’s a picture of an old man, and what seems like a torn page of a picture in the left corner of the book. At first, I was unsure if I was going to like this book or not. 

Now that I read this novel, I give it a three-star rating. Why do you ask? Well, I’ll explain. 

First, it was hard to decipher whether it was a young adult novel or a middle-grade novel. If you do a search engine inquiry through Google and type in “the giver,” you will see that it says it is a young adult novel. Personally, I do not think it’s a young adult.

It’s more middle grade. The story is about a twelve-year-old boy who learns from the Old Man’s memories the many complexities to our world. There is very little to no romance involved, and it’s pretty straight forward in terms of the plot. So, for argument’s sake, The Giver is an upper middle-grade novel. 

Second, after reading the entire story, which took me two days to read and analyze, I had many mixed feelings about the novel. 

Don’t get me wrong. I enjoyed the book. It had a clear beginning, middle, and end. I knew what the story’s agenda was about. These are all good points to consider. However, I felt like it was missing something. I can’t put my finger on what it was.

Perhaps the information about the characters and the world was sparse?  I did not like the ambiguous ending. After I read it, I understood why, but for me, as a writer and a reader, I prefer a clear ending. 

The emotional connection with any of the characters wasn’t there. I expected to feel more sympathetic for The Giver, the old Receiver of Memories, and Jonas.

I also wanted to know more backstory about the Community and the world that Jonas lived in. How did the Community start? Why did the world go into Sameness and not into the Elsewhere? Where did the Released people go?

There were some touching moments within the story, but even then, it wasn’t strong enough to get a reaction out of me. The Giver tells Jonas about Rosemary, his daughter. The Old Man explains to him how Rosemary was the Receiver of Memories and why they released her.

When The Giver gave Jonas happy memories, I expected to feel something. Instead, I felt emotionally disconnected from the scene. 

However, there were some awkward and some dark scenes in the book. Those resonated with me more so than the touching ones. The moments when Jonas has a ritual with his family in describing their feelings for the day and he speaks of dreams in the morning. I did feel uncomfortable. Lowry did a good job of creating uneasiness in those moments.

The one scene that terrified me and got a reaction out of me happens towards the end of the book. Jonas, with The Giver, watches a video of his father preparing the Released ceremony with a pair of twins. One twin goes away with the nurse, and Jonas’ father takes the other twin. Initially, Jonas thinks that his father will clean the baby up and make him comfy. Instead, he sees his father giving a lethal injection to a vein in the baby’s forehead. The baby dies in Jonas’ father’s arms. 

There were several intense themes the book touched upon, such as the importance of individual differences and the gravity of human emotions.

The book also discussed the weightiness of morals. Jonas often debated on when to tell the truth and when to tell a lie. He also considered when telling the truth or a lie was ethical and socially proper. It makes sense why a “children’s book” with these themes was taught in schools. 

Finally, I felt the world where Jonas lived didn’t feel believable. It didn’t present the alternative possibilities, such as a world without Sameness, a world without Release. The choice is either here, with Sameness and no color, or Elsewhere, with pain and suffering.

The story never mentions anything about the consequences of not living in the Community. What would happen if someone tried to escape the Community?

I did like The Giver, but it was certainly not my favorite. It had a great plot, and the world-building was interesting. The writing is up to standards, and it’s pretty easy to read. If you haven’t read this book yet as a school assignment, consider giving it a go.

Tagsbook reviewfictioncreative writingLois Lowrywriting
Previous Article

Crescent Moons Part 7

Next Article

Found Part Twenty Six

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Jasmine Bell

Jasmine Bell is a YA Writer and a Montessori Teacher, who lives in Orange County, California. She is a member of O.C Writers, SCBWI, RWA, and has attended the Southern California Writers Conference (SCWC). In April of 2020, Jasmine Bell was accepted for a writing internship for the online publishing company, Coffee House Writers. She has a bachelor of Arts in Creative Writing from University of Redlands. She has a crazy obsession over mermaids. When Jasmine isn’t writing, you may find her traveling the world, going on day trips to Disneyland, watching Netflix on her couch, or see her dance like no one is watching.

Related articles More from author

  • Storm storm
    HomeTravelPoliticsTechnologyEntertainmentMediaCreativityEnvironmentFamilyHealthRelationshipsMemories

    Why Take A Chance On Uncertain Weather? You Never Know Where The Road Will Lead You.

    February 18, 2019
    By Tracie Hicks
  • https://images.pexels.com/photos/247120/pexels-photo-247120.jpeg?auto=compress&cs=tinysrgb&dpr=2&h=650&w=940
    CreativityFictionHomeEntertainment

    The New Job: Emily

    April 1, 2019
    By Keely Messino
  • snowy mountains
    FamilyRelationshipsFictionMemoriesEnvironmentLifestyleTravel

    Broken Promises – Part One

    May 25, 2020
    By LC Ahl
  • RelationshipsPoetryHomeCreativityFamily

    Flaws

    June 15, 2020
    By Patricia Harris
  • EntertainmentLifestyleNonfictionCreativityFamily

    The Curse Of The Blinking Cursor

    May 11, 2020
    By Stephanie Wyatt
  • CreativityMemoriesEntertainmentNonfiction

    It Ain’t Crazy Being a Cat Lady

    February 24, 2020
    By Cameo J. Monroe

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may be interested

  • Hore Abby
    MemoriesTravelCultureEntertainmentCreativityHistoryFamilyRelationshipsFiction

    Pieces

  • CreativityFictionEntertainment

    The Watch Part 5

  • Night sky
    CultureFamilyHealth

    A Smart Person’s Guide To Insomnia

Timeline

  • January 30, 2023

    Ma Millie-3

  • January 30, 2023

    Blooming

  • January 30, 2023

    The Fool

  • January 30, 2023

    Enigma

  • January 30, 2023

    Why an Amazing Choir Director Absolutely Changes the World

Latest Comments

  • The Untouchable and Invisible World, is up at Coffee House Writers Magazine  – Ivor.Plumber/Poet
    on
    January 23, 2023
    […] Hello dear readers and followers, I now write for “Coffee House Writers” magazine on a ...

    The Untouchable and Invisible World

  • Ivor Steven
    on
    January 19, 2023
    Thank you, Derrick, for visiting my poem here at Coffee House Writers Magazine

    On Days Like These

  • COFFEE HOUSE WRITERS/POEM, By IVOR STEVEN – Ivor.Plumber/Poet
    on
    January 11, 2023
    […]   MORE FROM AUTHOR […]

    On Days Like These

  • Derrick Knight
    on
    January 10, 2023
    A beautiful tribute

    On Days Like These

  • On Days Like These, is up at Coffee House Writers Magerzine – Ivor.Plumber/Poet
    on
    January 9, 2023
    […] Hello dear readers and followers, I now write for “Coffee House Writers” magazine on a ...

    On Days Like These

Find us on Facebook

About us

  • coffeehousewriters3@gmail.com

Follow us

© Copyright 2018-2022 Coffee House Writers. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s administrator and owner is strictly prohibited.