Coffee House Writers

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Article Categories
    • Fiction
      • Action & Adventure
      • Fantasy
      • Historical Fiction
      • Horror
      • Mystery
      • Romance
      • Science Fiction
      • Speculative Fiction
      • Suspense & Thrillers
      • Westerns
      • Women’s Fiction
      • Women Sleuths
    • Nonfiction
      • Astrology & Tarot
      • Biographies
      • Business
      • Creativity
      • Creative Nonfiction
      • Cooking, Food & Drink
      • Culture
      • Current Affairs & Politics
      • Design, Fashion & Style
      • Entertainment
      • Environment
      • Health & Wellness
      • History
      • Home & Garden
      • Lifestyle
      • Media
      • Memoir & Autobiographies
      • Paranormal
      • Parenting & Family
      • Reviews
      • Science & Technology
      • Self-Help & Relationships
      • Spiritual & Religious
      • Sports
      • Travel
      • True Crime
    • Poetry
      • Acrostic
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Founder
  • Meet Our Admin
    • Chief Editors
    • Editors
  • Testimonials
  • Apply
  • Login

logo

Coffee House Writers

  • Home
  • Article Categories
    • Fiction
      • Action & Adventure
      • Fantasy
      • Historical Fiction
      • Horror
      • Mystery
      • Romance
      • Science Fiction
      • Speculative Fiction
      • Suspense & Thrillers
      • Westerns
      • Women’s Fiction
      • Women Sleuths
    • Nonfiction
      • Astrology & Tarot
      • Biographies
      • Business
      • Creativity
      • Creative Nonfiction
      • Cooking, Food & Drink
      • Culture
      • Current Affairs & Politics
      • Design, Fashion & Style
      • Entertainment
      • Environment
      • Health & Wellness
      • History
      • Home & Garden
      • Lifestyle
      • Media
      • Memoir & Autobiographies
      • Paranormal
      • Parenting & Family
      • Reviews
      • Science & Technology
      • Self-Help & Relationships
      • Spiritual & Religious
      • Sports
      • Travel
      • True Crime
    • Poetry
      • Acrostic
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Founder
  • Meet Our Admin
    • Chief Editors
    • Editors
  • Testimonials
  • Apply
  • Login
  • Underneath the Surface of Optimism

  • Climbing the Stairs

  • There’s a Crack in the Floor

  • Dogs

  • Zombie Killer Squad: Chapter Ten

  • Of Lockets and Pomegranates: Chapter 9

  • The Memories of Us

  • Well…Do You?

  • Meetings

  • Worth it in the End

  • Lover of the Queen: Procession

  • Protest

  • The Invitation: Part 5

  • In Defense of Doing Nothing

  • Teen Witch’s Survival Guide: Chapter 4

  • Speak Peace

  • Uncle Albert’s Ghostly Encounter

  • Types of Words

  • My Savior Came Flipping Tables

  • Of Lockets and Pomegranates: Chapter 8

Prose PoetryRhyming Poems
Home›Poetry›Prose Poetry›Which Witch is Which?

Which Witch is Which?

By Olivia Fleming
November 17, 2025
38
0
Share:
An art doll held by strings.
Sivani Bandaru / Unsplash
0
(0)

In a dark, dark corner of a dark, dark lair 

behind a dark, dark door down some dark, dark stairs 

sits a pale and handsome woman with some dark, dark hair…

 

‘Good evening,’ she purrs as you pull up a chair 

‘Can I be of help in my humble abode?

Are you scared? Are you lost and all alone?’

 

Her eyes are quick and her fingers are cold 

her skin is plump but her soul is old 

And with one soft word she’ll make you fold 

but beware! 

she’ll eat you whole 

steamed, succulent and sweet 

she’ll pick her teeth 

with your bones –  

 

‘Hush… the wind moans,’ she speaks, do you hear? 

‘The witching hour is near…’

 

You gulp nervously and look into the fire,

it twirls and dances as you lift your gaze higher

and let your eyes adjust to the dark, dark room.

Candlelight bleeds slowly, softly, in the gloom. 

 

The room is cluttered with trinkets of old,

forgotten lockets accented with gold,

leather bound books and secret nooks

filled with decayed and curling pages –

photos of clung lovers lost to the ages 

 

‘So.. what do you say…?’ she smiles and cocks her head,

a coquettish smile on those red raw lips,

a seductive curve to her black satin hips.

‘Would you like to stay? Or shall I send you on your merry way?’ 

 

Silence.

 

You are less scared than expected. In fact, a part of you feels even slightly tempted by the whet of her lip and the gleam in her eye –

 

Don’t do it!!!

Although she may look like a treat she is far from sweet.

She’s hungry for life, so she’ll eat and she’ll eat ’til her belly is swollen and her greed is halted.

She’ll roast you n’ toast you – your flesh hot and salted – 

‘You’ll never win!!’

She hisses poison onto my skin, and throws me down to the hearth with a crash, my face burns in the ash and I bite my tongue and bow my head… accepting my wrong… 

For you see – I am just the humble narrator, I have no place in this story.

I’m afraid I can’t stop it being gory. I let life pass me by in the blink of an eye for I am helpless to help, and helpless to be any more than just a pale mimicry

of the person I see before me 

you, a tragic victim, protagonist no more 

you’ve stepped into her story, the villain’s whore,

your fate is sealed, and that I cannot undo 

you’ll say yes like the many before you. 

 

I am a player in someone’s else’s tale,  

a shadow that watches, a shadow that waits 

A shadow that sits silently beside the grate 

of her fire

Though it cannot warm me

I despise her 

Though you must abhor me 

For my inability to act.

Instead, I sit back

and watch it all play out…..

Over and over again.

 

This place held colour once, under blankets of dust and cobwebbed crust lies a red velvet sofa, yellowed and stained silk curtains cover a grandfather clock, tick tock, tick tock, tick tock, TICK TOCK… 

 

You pick up a rock and knock her on the head. Hard. Bloody. Her brains spatter and congeal against the floor, against me, and onto your face. Metallic. Sour. 

 

Huh. Wasn’t that easy?

 

I bend forward. 

 

She still bleeds the same..

Strawberry heart jam on toast.

 

I straighten up. I look at you. 

 

Well, dear reader. What are you going to do?


Editor: Erynn Crittenden

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you enjoyed this post...

Follow us on social media!

Oh no!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Tagsscary storyFreeform Poetrymetafiction
Previous Article

Aging: A Lyrical Reflection

Next Article

You Can’t Always Get What You Want

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0

Olivia Fleming

Related articles More from author

  • Soul Soothers
    Poetry

    Soul Soothers

    January 31, 2022
    By Calpernia Charles
  • DoverDemon
    CultureNonfictionHistory

    Massachusetts Dover Demon

    February 1, 2021
    By VL Jones
  • image of a man drinking coffee on a sofa with cat
    CreativityPoetryMemoir & Autobiographies

    Coffee Cup Moments

    November 13, 2023
    By Chasity Gaines
  • Poetry

    As You

    August 17, 2020
    By Jessica Niziolek
  • A pair of red leather high-heeled pumps
    Parenting & FamilyPoetryMemoir & Autobiographies

    My Mother’s Strength

    January 22, 2024
    By Shannon Richards
  • blooming blue poppy flower against a blurred background
    Poetry

    Everyday Beauty

    March 25, 2024
    By Amber Jenkins

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may be interested

  • https://www.pexels.com/photo/abstract-blur-bright-christmas-286198/
    EnvironmentCultureCreativityParenting & FamilyMemoir & Autobiographies

    December Is The Month Of Christmas

  • hands holding stone
    PoetryLifestyle

    My Heart Of Stone

  • A hallway with green walls and gray floors that shows a lit baby blue brick wall and window in the distance.
    NonfictionCreative Nonfiction

    Drowning Out the Noise

Timeline

  • December 1, 2025

    Underneath the Surface of Optimism

  • December 1, 2025

    Climbing the Stairs

  • December 1, 2025

    There’s a Crack in the Floor

  • December 1, 2025

    Dogs

  • December 1, 2025

    Zombie Killer Squad: Chapter Ten

Latest Comments

  • Susi
    on
    November 3, 2025
    Beautiful, Ivor!

    Paddling In Time

  • Ivor Steven
    on
    October 30, 2025
    Thank you for your gracious words, Violet 😍📖🌏

    It Is Manuscript Time

  • violet
    on
    October 27, 2025
    So aptly 'you' Ivor! I love it!

    It Is Manuscript Time

  • Ivor Steven
    on
    October 24, 2025
    Many thanks for visiting my poem here at Coffee House Writers Magazine, and thank you for ...

    Paddling In Time

  • Ivor Steven
    on
    October 24, 2025
    Many thanks for visiting my poem here at Coffee House Writers Magazine, and thank you for ...

    Paddling In Time

About us

  • coffeehousewriters3@gmail.com

Donate to Coffee House Writers

Coindrop.to me

Follow us

© Copyright 2018-2025 Coffee House Writers. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s administrator and owner is strictly prohibited. Privacy Policy · Disclaimer